• Home
    • About Charles and Co Solicitors Birmingham
    • Privacy Policy
    • Complaints Procedure
  • Expertise
    • Commercial / Property
    • Conveyancing
    • Family Law
    • Higher Education Law Solicitors
    • Insolvency
    • Landlord and Tenant
    • Litigation
  • Our People
    • Jagdip Chahal
    • Gurjit Chahal
    • Ranjit Tiwana
    • Sukhvir Gill
    • Joanne Herbert
    • Rajbant Sangha
    • Aman Rana
    • Daljit Singh Kular
    • Jeevan Tiwana
  • News
  • FAQ’s
  • Contact
    • Area of Coverage
  • Join Us
  • Home
    • About Charles and Co Solicitors Birmingham
    • Privacy Policy
    • Complaints Procedure
  • Expertise
    • Commercial / Property
    • Conveyancing
    • Family Law
    • Higher Education Law Solicitors
    • Insolvency
    • Landlord and Tenant
    • Litigation
  • Our People
    • Jagdip Chahal
    • Gurjit Chahal
    • Ranjit Tiwana
    • Sukhvir Gill
    • Joanne Herbert
    • Rajbant Sangha
    • Aman Rana
    • Daljit Singh Kular
    • Jeevan Tiwana
  • News
  • FAQ’s
  • Contact
    • Area of Coverage
  • Join Us
Toggle panel Social icons
Category:

Fitness to Practise

Browse:
  • Home
  • Fitness to Practise

Stand Up For Your Rights

by admin in Fitness to Practise, Higher Education Law

The Higher Education Law Specialist at Charles and Co Solicitors, Sukhvir Gill, has noticed an increasing trend in matters relating to University Fitness to Practise processes, in that students are not always getting a fair opportunity to test the evidence against them. Without good legal representation a number of students are being withdrawn from Universities, despite incomplete evidence being presented, no witnesses being called and no opportunity for the student to examine the word of others.

This is not a fair process and more needs to be done to ensure that University Fitness Practise Policies are in line with those of the professional bodies that have delegated their power to the Higher Education Institutions.

Not every student instructs a Solicitor early on, primarily because a number of Universities advise against it. A number of students try and handle the situation themselves, but when you think that a whole team behind the scenes at the University are collaborating and working together to present a case against a student, the odds are really stacked against the lone student. Also, once a fully qualified member of your professional body, you would seek out legal support if you were up before a disciplinary or Fitness to Practise Panel. It should be the same for students and they should be actively advised of their right to have legal assistance by the Universities.

At Charles and Co our Higher Education Law Specialist represents students on a variety of professional degree courses that are governed by a professional body and subject to Fitness to Practise Regulations. We have successfully defended students in such cases and have ensured that students continue on with their course and graduate to join their chosen profession.

Our Higher Education Law Specialist has also recently had a high proportion of postgraduate clients, particularly those trying to achieve a PhD. Supervision is key and without good quality supervision a student’s progress can be seriously hindered. However, we also recognise that many students are working within a small community of Professors and experts and do not want to draw attention to themselves by being perceived as difficult. Often students will put up with poor quality supervision and limited research facilities until it’s all too late.

More and more PhD students have become disappointed with the level of support and backing from either their supervisor, or the Faculty, or in the worst cases both. It has been really hard to shift the mind-set that speaking up, in a well-articulated manner, will not necessarily jeopardise your positon within the Faculty.

We have also been astounded by the deliberate and blatant disregard some Faculties have towards University Regulations. It would be prudent to go through the Faculty Regulations governing your PhD, Master, MPhil and cross-referencing what is says should be happening versus what is actually happening.

When you think about the levels of fees involved in this area of study, not to mention time put into research, it is important that you do not let uneasy matters ride along for years, whilst the University rack up the fees.

There are always policies and procedures in place; it is just getting the University to follow them that can be the issue. We cannot stress enough the importance of a student feeling empowered enough to challenge the University if things just are not as you would expect. Universities are amenable to our involvement because it helps create that barrier to get things fixed for the better of all involved. In most cases Universities do actually want students to be successful in their academic progression, they want you to be able to tell others about what a great University they are if nothing else.

 

Fitness to Practise – A Fair Hearing?

by admin in Fitness to Practise

Anyone who has ever been involved in the Fitness to Practise (FTP) process will know just how serious and stressful it can be. It is not something to be taken lightly, and whereas in the professional arena there is no doubt that anyone subjected to the process would require and warrant qualified legal representation, it would seem that for students facing the same in the University setting, the automatic right to legal representation is just not there.

Representing students on a daily basis on a number of issues, I have often come across having to justify to Higher Education Institutions why a student should be allowed legal representation, not only at the hearing, but during the investigation stage too. That cannot be right or fair?

FTP is something that hangs over all medical, dental, social work, nursing and midwifery students, to name a few, throughout their studies. I have been involved in cases for all types of students and it never ceases to amaze me the level of inequality some students have had to endure before they even reach me.

The basic principles of a fair trial, underpinned by Article 6 of the Human Rights Act 1998, appear to be of no concern to many a University FTP Panel.

I have a number of FTP cases at present, all at different stages of the process. It goes without saying that being instructed from the outset of the matter, is always best. You get to navigate the case from the start and prevent any missteps on the part of the client. You get to keep a watchful eye on the University and I also find that once the University know they are being watched, their efforts to be fair are that much greater. Of course not all students can afford qualified legal representation, and some are put off getting legal help by either the University or even the Student Union. It is suggested to students that if you get legal help 1) you have something to hide and 2) you will be treated much harsher. Not true.

Not every student instructs early on, a number try and handle the situation themselves, but when you think that a whole team behind the scenes at the University are collaborating and working together to get you out, the odds are really stacked against the lone student.

I have a case at present where the student has been through the whole process alone, including the appeal stage. The University took in excess of six months to investigate the case and then gave the student a mere 10 working days to submit their statement and evidence, sound fair? The University provided no signed witness statements and produced no witnesses at the FTP Hearing itself. This did not seem to perturb the FTP Panel, who despite not hearing a shred of evidence, found the student unfit and withdrew them from the course.

Universities have to accept, whereas it may not be a court of law, FTPs are quasi-legal proceedings, the outcomes of which fundamentally impact the students’ career and future life trajectory. Findings cannot be made without the basic legal principles, as embodied by Article 6, being adhered to.  

Recent Posts

  • Sexual Misconduct

    With the #Me Too movement the goalposts governing the interplay…

  • Covid 19 Impacting Your Studies?

    With this global pandemic comes much uncertainty, but none more…

  • Mental Health and Universities

    The transition from school to University is difficult for most,…

  • Stand Up For Your Rights

    The Higher Education Law Specialist at Charles and Co Solicitors,…

  • Fitness to Practise – A Fair Hearing?

    Anyone who has ever been involved in the Fitness to…

Recent Comments

  • Let sleeping dogs lie v Finality on Divorce? - Charles and co Solicitors | Legal Specialists Birmingham on Gurjit Chahal
  • Plus Business Solutions develop Charles and Co Solicitors Brand New Website - Plus Business Solutions on Litigation
  • Plus Business Solutions develop Charles and Co Solicitors Brand New Website - Plus Business Solutions on Commercial / Property

Categories

  • Academic Appeal
  • Commercial Law
  • Conveyancing Law
  • Covid 19
  • Education Tuition fees
  • Family Law
  • Fitness to Practise
  • Higher Education Law
  • Matrimonial Finance
  • Mental Health at University
  • New Website Launch
  • Office of the Independent Adjudicator
  • Oral Exams and Extra Time
  • PHD
  • Plagiarism
  • Student Union Advice
  • Uncategorized
  • University Complaints
  • University Compliants
  • University Decisions

Our expertise

  • Commercial / Property
  • Conveyancing
  • Family Law
  • Higher Education Law Solicitors
  • Immigration
  • Insolvency
  • Landlord and Tenant
  • Litigation
  • Get In Touch

Call Our Experts

16 - 17 Caroline Street, Birmingham, B3 1TR

0121 236 1985

E-Mail: info@charlesandco.org

Charles and Co Solicitors

16 - 17 Caroline Street, Jewellery Quarter, Birmingham, West Midlands B3 1TR

0121 236 1985

E-Mail: info@charlesandco.org

Latest tweets

Sukhvir Gill Follow me
18 days ago
200 days ago
331 days ago

Latest News

  • Sexual Misconduct

    With the #Me Too movement the goalposts governing the interplay…

  • Covid 19 Impacting Your Studies?

    With this global pandemic comes much uncertainty, but none more…

  • Mental Health and Universities

    The transition from school to University is difficult for most,…

Copyright reserved 2017

Translate »